Analysis of Book

by

Bader, Barbara, American Picturebooks from Noah's Ark to the Beast Within, New York: Macmillan, 1976; Bodmer, George, ‘The night Max wore his wolf suit’: Borders between Childhood and the Animal Story,” ChLA Annual Meeting, Roanoke, VA, 23 June, 2000; Marcus, Leonard S., A Caldecott Celebration: Six Artists and Their Paths to the Caldecott Medal, New York: Walker, 1998; Spitz, Ellen Handler, Inside Picture Books, New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999.

Page-by-Page Analysis * First picture: Max looks angry in the picture; he wears his "wolf suit" (why?), and is hammering nails into the wall; a teddy bear (or something - maybe a stuffed wolf) is hanging from coat hanger. Much suggestion of "acting-out" behavior, serious bad actions or psychological disturbance, but the text refers only to "mischief" - perhaps an example of the text contradicting the picture.




* Second picture: Max is chasing the dog (which looks like the hero of Higgledy Piggledy Pop, which was based on Sendak's own dog); the background shows monster picture "by Max" nailed to wall, suggesting earlier instances of "mischief" have made him familiar with the wild things. Query: the picture is hung neatly - does this suggest perhaps that his mother has put it up for display? If so, what are the implications for Max's relationship with his family?



* Third picture: He is closed in his bedroom, still wearing wolf suit, still looking very angry. The text tells us the anger is directed at his mother, who has called him "Wild Thing" and sent him to bed without supper after he shouted "I'll eat you up!"



* Fourth picture: The forest is growing in Max's room, and Max now appears almost nonchalant. (The imagery of the forest growing out of the bed room echoes a similar description in George MacDonald's work, which Sendak is familiar with.)



* Fifth picture: The forest grows even more, the bedroom fades into background, and the moon appears brighter. But the illustration here resembles a theatrical set, perhaps suggesting that the ensuing events are being acted out in the theatre of Max's imagination; note the line across the bottom, just behind Max, as if this were a painted screen. Max now is smiling and laughing into his hand, enjoying a joke? - no longer angry, but ratheras if he is getting the last laugh on Mom.



* Sixth picture: The bedroom has disappeared; nothing is visible but the forest, and Max has his back to us. "The walls became the world all around" - the child's imagination converts an unpleasant environment into a world of adventure which he controls, and also literalizes what he feels: when he is confined to his room, the room does become the world all around him, or all the world to him. The picture now occupies a full page, having grown larger to this point; for the first time in the book, the space devoted to text and the space devoted to picture are in equilibrium. From here to the book's climax, the pictorial elements will continue to expand at the expense of the text space (perhaps a reflection of the dominance of the imagination); once Max's "wild-thing" energy is spent, the pictures shrink again until in the final spread there is only text, no picture at all.



* Seventh picture: The ocean with the boat appears, and Max looks peaceful, happy.



* Eighth picture: The text (here and on the previous page) suggests passage through time, perhaps evoking the sense that a change in behavior comes with maturity, achieved through time. Max sees the first "wild thing" and looks worried; he raises hands/paws to fend off the sea creature.



* Ninth picture: The monsters all seem kind of cuddly, with soft edges and friendly expressions, even though the text describes them as terrible in many senses. Again, there is an apparent contradiction between picture and text. Max now does not seem apprehensive, but rather angry at them - as we might imagine his mother (never seen) to be with him. He looks mildly disgusted. The number of wild things suggests that Max’s imagination has fragmented the aggression they represent, so as better to control them (Spitz 130).



* Tenth picture: Role reversal: Max shouts "Be still" and tames the monsters by facing them directly without blinking. He acts to them as Mother sought to act to him, but they obey better than he did. He is in charge, and they look frightened. Psychologically, this scene represents a mastering of the violent "wild-thing" impulses - we can only deal with these impulses by facing them directly.



* Eleventh picture: The cuddly wild things now bow to him; he appears haughty as he is addressed as "king of all wild things." He is completely in control, as earlier (in the "real world" of home) he was completely out of control.



* Twelfth picture: This is the first of three illustrations that each occupies an entire two-page spread, with no text. The imagination has achieved a release as the monsters seem to be playing a game. Max joins in, his mouth open wide, yelling. They are creating a "wild rumpus" in the forest, which is still his bedroom.



* Thirteenth picture: Max looks happy, with the monsters joining in the fun.



* Fourteenth picture: Triumphant Max, as in the previous two illustrations, is at the center of the two-page spread. The frame has become almost completely filled with monsters, but they remain benign and under Max's control, as evidenced by his riding atop one of them, wielding his sceptre.



* Fifteenth picture: Max treats the wild things as he was treated, but he is lonely as king of the wild things - for the first time since arriving in this place, he looks sad in the picture.



* Sixteenth picture: The verbal repetition of Max's threat to his mother ("We'll eat you up") is transformed into an expression of love (consistent with the sometimes over-exuberant behavior of aunts and uncles to a young child, which was one of the models for Sendak's wild things). To what extent is Max's initial threat also an expression of love? Max waves back happily as he leaves the wild things for home.



* Seventeenth picture: Max sails home, looking a little sad - contrite maybe?


* Eighteenth picture: Max appears very happy and tired as he arrives home to find his supper awaiting him, and he is already undergoing a transformation back into boy - he has put back the hood of his wolf suit. Critic George Bodmer has pointed out that Max's wolf costume represents a role that he plays; at the end of the book, having slipped out of the role of "wild thing," he also appears for the first time without the wolf suit fully in place.Note that the moon in the window is now full, whereas in the earlier scenes of the bedroom, it was a crescent - thus the illustration suggests that the seemingly fanciful notion of great periods of time elapsing, as Max "sailed in and out of weeks and almost over a year" is perhaps not so fanciful after all. The full moon is also a symbol of fulfillment or completeness, consistent with Max's apparent integration of his negative impulses through his visit to the wild things.